1. Mikey’s Late Night Slice
If you’ve walked around Columbus after a concert, you’ve probably seen the line outside Mikey’s Late Night Slice. This spot has basically redefined pizza for night owls in Ohio. They serve up big, cheesy slices with crispy crust, perfect for anyone who wants something quick but full of flavor. The menu leans into classics—try their pepperoni or the Spicy-Ass Pepperoni, which really lives up to its name. The real kicker is their famous Slut Sauce, a tangy, dreamy dip that’s become legendary for regulars.
Here’s what you shouldn’t miss at Mikey’s:
- Giant, foldable slices that taste great whether it’s 7pm or 2am
- A laid-back, quirky vibe that’s totally unpretentious
- Sauces and dips you’ll want to take home by the bottle
| Feature | Details |
| Slices Size | Oversized |
| Sauce Variety | Signature Slut Sauce & more |
| Best Time Visited | Late nights, after events |
| Price Range | $ – Affordable |
Sometimes, you just want a no-fuss pizza fix that hits the spot. Mikey’s totally gets that.
While you’re chowing down at Mikey’s, you might overhear talk about business brokers and local business for sale brokers scouting for their next investment spot. Pizza shops like Mikey’s are often seen as a gold mine for automotive business brokers or anyone browsing internet business for sale listings. But for most of us, it’s just the place to get really good pizza when you need it most.
2. Mama Santa’s
Mama Santa’s is tucked into Cleveland’s Little Italy, and it’s one of those spots that feels like it’s been around forever. The pizzas here have a reputation for a thin, crisp crust, sweet tomato sauce, and just the right amount of cheese. If someone’s never had their massive sheet pizza, they’ve missed out on a local legend. People usually show up in groups and share slices right out of the pan, especially after spending the day exploring art galleries or when looking for a quick bite after checking out potential business for sale brokers in the area.
Some reasons fans keep coming back:
- The dough is made fresh daily, and you can taste the difference.
- Family recipes haven’t really changed since the place opened in 1961.
- It’s a regular spot for everyone from college kids to automotive business brokers needing a lunch break.
Here’s a quick rundown of what to expect if you swing by Mama Santa’s:
| Dish | Description | Price Range |
| Cheese Pizza | Simple, classic flavors | $10–$16 |
| Meat Lovers | Loaded with sausage, beef | $13–$20 |
| Sheet Pizza | Great for big groups | $22–$28 |
Sometimes, after sharing a pizza at Mama Santa’s, you’ll overhear tables swapping stories about big sales or someone looking for an internet business for sale. The place has a way of sparking connections over good food, whether you’re in town for work or just hungry for something familiar.
It’s hard not to feel at home here, and based on the crowds, a lot of Ohioans agree.
3. Dewey’s Pizza
If you’re looking for a fun, casual night out with some of the best pizza in Ohio, Dewey’s Pizza deserves your attention. Dewey’s has built its reputation on a creative menu and an energy that stands out from your average pizza joint. You walk in to see the team working open kitchens, tossing dough high and going all-in on those inventive toppings.
One thing I like about Dewey’s is how they keep their specialty pizzas interesting. Here’s a quick snapshot of their most popular pies:
| Pizza Name | Toppings | Crust Options |
| Green Lantern | Pesto, Mozzarella, Artichokes, Red Onions | Regular, Thin, Gluten-Free |
| Edgar Allan Poe | Olive Oil, Mozzarella, Mushrooms, Goat Cheese, Walnuts | Regular, Thin |
| Southwest BBQ Chicken | BBQ Sauce, Smoked Cheddar, Chicken, Corn | Regular, Thin, Gluten-Free |
A few reasons people actually love Dewey’s:
- The dough gets made fresh, always.
- They let you customize everything, so everyone in the group is happy.
- Staff are friendly, and the vibe works for families, dates, or just a quick lunch.
No matter where you’re coming from—whether it’s after a meeting with business brokers, checking out an internet business for sale, or even hanging with your crew of automotive business brokers—Dewey’s feels like a reward at the end of a long day.
Honestly, Dewey’s doesn’t try to do too much. They focus on pizza and nail it every single time. And if you walk in on a busy night, don’t stress—your pie is worth the wait.
4. Tommy’s Pizza
Tommy’s Pizza has been a Columbus tradition for decades, and anyone who grew up nearby probably has strong opinions about their favorite order. The shop is old-school, so don’t expect flashy décor or trendy toppings—this place is about comfort, nostalgia, and pizza made the same way year after year. What sets Tommy’s apart is its super crispy, cracker-thin crust that provides a satisfying crunch in every bite.
If you’re someone who likes the classic approach, you’ll appreciate the fresh toppings, tangy sauce, and generous helpings of cheese. Here’s how locals say Tommy’s stands out:
- Classic square-cut, Ohio-style pizza
- Super thin and crunchy crust that’s almost addictive
- Familiar menu with no-nonsense pricing
| Signature Pizza | Type | Notable Toppings |
| Tommy’s Deluxe | Square-cut thin | Pepperoni, sausage |
| Cheese Lovers | Round thin or thick | Extra cheese, provolone |
| Veggie Supreme | Thin crust | Mushrooms, peppers |
Every time you walk into Tommy’s, there’s this familiar, warm feeling—like you’ve stepped into a memory from childhood.
Tommy’s is just the right spot if you cherish local traditions and want pizza the way it’s been made in Ohio for generations. And as a bonus for pizza-loving entrepreneurs, the steady foot traffic and recognition Tommy’s enjoys may inspire dreams of your own food spot—although you might want to chat with business brokers or business for sale brokers to see what’s on the market. If you’re eyeing an automotive business broker or even searching for an internet business for sale, maybe you’ll take some pizza inspiration with you. Tommy’s is the kind of place that reminds you it’s possible to do one thing really well and keep customers coming back for decades.
5. Pizza Cottage
Pizza Cottage is a spot that a lot of Ohio locals recommend—especially if you want something consistent and hearty. Their thick, cheesy slices and crowd-pleasing crust have made them a favorite for families and college students alike.
If you’re curious, here’s a quick breakdown of what regulars keep coming back for:
- Reliable quality no matter which location you pick.
- A varied menu, featuring not just pizza but also strombolis, subs, and salads.
- Plenty of space for gatherings, making it popular for birthday parties and casual hangouts.
| Menu Item | Average Price | Portion Size |
| Large Cheese Pizza | $14.99 | 8 slices |
| Stromboli | $7.99 | Individually sized |
| Chicken Caesar Salad | $9.49 | Full bowl |
If you’ve ever been to Pizza Cottage, you know their pizza hits the spot after a long day or even late at night when you’re catching up with friends. Even folks working as business brokers or dealing with an automotive business broker sometimes need a good slice to fuel long negotiations. It’s also a quiet favorite among business for sale brokers looking to unwind after meetings—or maybe scroll listings for an internet business for sale on their phones in between bites.
Sometimes, it’s just about finding that one pizza place where you know nobody will complain about the choices. Pizza Cottage does that with no fuss.
It’s worth mentioning—if you ever wonder, “how long can pizza sit out,” the answer usually depends on toppings, but food safety rules suggest eating within two hours if it’s left at room temperature. No matter what, Pizza Cottage is one of those pizza stops you keep in your back pocket for any occasion.
6. Gatto’s Pizza
Walking into Gatto’s Pizza, you can smell everything fresh coming out of the oven. This spot has a pretty loyal following, and after just one slice, it’s not hard to see why people mention it when they’re talking about the best pizza in Ohio. There’s nothing fancy—just classic Ohio-style pizza made with attention you notice in every bite. If you’re out with friends or grabbing something quick after work, it’s easy to get hooked on their crispy edges and gooey cheese.
The sausage and pepperoni combo is absolutely worth trying if you want something filling and full of flavor. Regulars seem to order it again and again. People even talk about how the crust has just the right crunch but still feels chewy inside. Here’s a quick look at what regulars love most when they visit:
- Slices are cut into thick, satisfying squares
- Real mozzarella (not some tasteless cheese blend)
- Their tangy tomato sauce, homemade daily
In comparison to other pizza joints, the menu at Gatto’s is pretty straightforward. There aren’t a ton of crazy toppings or fusion flavors—just top choices and reliable service. It kind of reminds you how simple, old-school pizza can still stand out in a state with so many options. For folks thinking about the future, it’s also interesting that community businesses like Gatto’s sometimes reach out to business brokers or look at business for sale brokers when planning what’s next. That’s probably why, if you’re in the neighborhood, you’ll see locals chatting about everything from new internet business for sale ideas to the latest deals from automotive business brokers—and often, Gatto’s is their meeting spot.
There are nights when Gatto’s is packed, and you realize pizza from here just hits the spot when you want something classic. It’s the kind of place you remember visiting with friends, sharing a booth, and talking about nothing in particular, but the pizza stays in your mind all week.
7. Adriatico’s New York Style
If you’re ever around Columbus, Adriatico’s New York Style is a local classic that every pizza fan should know about. Big, cheesy slices and crust you can actually fold—Adriatico’s brings that New York feeling right to Ohio. There’s nothing fancy here, just straightforward pies loaded with toppings and enough cheese to make anyone happy.
What really stands out is how you can order a massive Sicilian pizza that could feed everyone at your table (or just yourself if you’re feeling confident). People love the crispy edges and that perfect balance of sauce and cheese that never feels heavy. If you’re craving varieties, their menu goes beyond pepperoni—think BBQ chicken or veggie options that aren’t just afterthoughts.
Here’s what sets Adriatico’s apart from other spots:
- Super fast service, even when it’s busy
- Fresh, never bland sauce that makes the pizza pop
- Flexible options for parties, solo meals, or those weird times when your friend wants wings instead
| Pizza Type | Size Options | Specialty Toppings |
| New York Style | S, M, L, XL | Pepperoni, Sausage, Veggie |
| Sicilian Pan | Full, Half | BBQ Chicken, Deluxe |
Sometimes, after a hectic day calling business brokers or searching for a new spot with business for sale brokers, sinking your teeth into a steamy piece of New York-style pizza is the reset you never knew you needed.
Whether you’re heading there after work at the local automotive business brokers office or celebrating with friends, Adriatico’s stands as a must-try. They may not have an internet business for sale, but they sure know how to run a pizzeria that keeps people coming back.
8. Angelo’s Pizza
Angelo’s Pizza in Lakewood is one of those legendary Ohio spots where locals just can’t get enough. The outside is simple, but the inside? You’re hit with the smell of fresh dough, baking cheese, and garlic. Their thick, buttery crust with that crunchy edge – honestly, it stands out from a lot of other pizza shops. You’ll notice families, busy workers, and even nearby business brokers stopping in for a quick lunch. It’s that kind of local spot that pulls in everyone, whether you just discovered an internet business for sale or your kids want pizza after soccer.
The white pizza and the classic deep-dish pepperoni are absolute must-trys. The cheese? Always gooey. The sauce? Tangy but never too much. Add-ons like sausage or veggies are plentiful, not the usual skimpy toppings you see elsewhere.
Here’s what people say makes Angelo’s memorable:
- The crust: Golden, thick, still somehow light.
- Cheesy, generous toppings.
- Casual, welcoming atmosphere – expect quick service, especially if you call ahead.
| Menu Favorite | Crust Type | What Makes It Special |
| Deep-Dish Pepperoni | Thick | Buttery, crisp edge |
| White Pizza | Regular | Garlic oil, blend of cheeses |
| Veggie Supreme | Thick/Thin | Fresh, locally sourced |
Sometimes, waiting for a table at Angelo’s can take a bit, especially on weekends, but the payoff is worth it. Personally, I’d take this wait any day just to get that cheesy slice. For anyone in Ohio – pizza lover, business for sale broker, or regular folks – this is a spot you shouldn’t skip.
9. Samosky’s Homestyle Pizzeria
There’s just something special about a pizza shop that feels like home. Samosky’s Homestyle Pizzeria in Valley City takes your classic pizza night up a notch. Locals swear by their thick, pillowy crusts and inventive toppings—they always seem extra fresh, like they were chopped and grated to order. Samosky’s crowd-favorites include their award-winning BBQ Chicken Pizza and their Sicilian deep dish, which is the sort of comfort food that gets people talking after just one bite.
If you’re looking to try a pizza spot that’s stayed true to tradition (there’s no ‘internet business for sale’ vibe here—just real folks making good food), here are a few reasons Samosky’s stands out:
- They use a family dough recipe, made fresh daily, never frozen
- Pies are customizable, so you can add local produce or even their homemade sausage
- They’ve quietly won regional pizza contests without changing their down-to-earth vibe
| Pizza Type | Description | Popularity (1-5) |
| BBQ Chicken | Tangy sauce, smoked chicken | 5 |
| Sicilian Deep Dish | Thick, cheesy, hearty | 4.5 |
| Veggie Deluxe | Local veggies, rich sauce | 4 |
Samosky’s is where you go when you want a break from chain restaurants or complicated menus. Every slice feels like it was made for you, and honestly, you can taste the care in every bite.
While Samosky’s isn’t likely to be bought out by major business brokers or listed with business for sale brokers anytime soon, that’s exactly what fans love. It’s local, reliable, and genuine—making it a must-stop for any pizza lover exploring Ohio.
10. Harvest Pizzeria
Harvest Pizzeria is a solid choice for anyone looking to eat fresh, handcrafted pizza in Ohio. This spot is serious about everything local—sourcing ingredients straight from area farms, which makes a real difference when you bite into a slice. Their menu isn’t cluttered, but every option has its fans.
If you’re not into the usual heavy pizzas, Harvest Pizzeria does it lighter—though you won’t miss out on flavor. Even their gluten-free crust gets high marks, which surprised me since those usually fall flat. Place gets busy, but it’s never stuffy. You get the feeling the staff cares about their work; there’s not a business broker or business for sale broker type around, just people who love food.
Some things folks especially talk about:
- House-made sauces that aren’t too sweet
- Great for pizza traditionalists and people looking for new combos
- Vegan and vegetarian-friendly options that actually taste good
Here’s a quick look at a few of their pizzas and pricing:
| Pizza Name | Price (Medium) | Notable Ingredient |
| Spicy Yuma | $16.00 | Peppadew peppers |
| Pineapple Sriracha | $16.50 | Roasted jalapeños |
| Butternut Squash | $17.00 | Sage cream |
| Margherita | $15.00 | Fresh mozzarella |
If you’re used to fast food or franchise pizza, Harvest Pizzeria feels different—more like a chill evening out than grabbing something on the run.
There’s no pushy pitch here, just really solid pizza and a relaxed vibe. It’s honestly the kind of place where you’d swap stories over a slice. While you probably won’t chat with automotive business brokers or overhear internet business for sale deals at the table next to you, the friendly staff might just remember your name next time. Get there early if you don’t want to wait.
Wrapping Up the Pizza Hunt
So, there you have it—some of the best pizza spots in Ohio, all worth checking out. Whether you like thin crust, deep dish, or something a little different, there’s a place on this list for you. Honestly, it’s hard to pick a favorite because each spot has its own thing going on. Next time you’re craving pizza, maybe try one of these places instead of your usual. Who knows, you might just find a new go-to. And if you think we missed a great spot, let us know. There’s always room for more pizza adventures.
